We have answered some of the most commonly asked
questions about the Open Letter to Beth Moore here.
If you are unfamiliar with the events surrounding this letter, please read
An Open Letter to Beth Moore – Timeline of Events.
Dear Mrs. Moore,
Hello – we hope this finds you doing well.
We as female Bible teachers ourselves write this letter to you in hopes of receiving clarification of your views on an important issue: homosexuality.
In the last few years, particularly since 2016, you have been very vocal in your opposition to misogyny and racism. Anytime a story with so much of a whiff of these issues comes to the forefront you are very quick to speak out. The actions of the Covington kids, for example, you said “is so utterly antichrist it reeks of the vomit of hell” in a January 19, 2019 tweet; a tweet you deleted, without apology to the kids, once the full video was shown that portrayed a very different reality than what initial reporting suggested.
It is this Johnny-on-the-spot readiness to engage issues related to misogyny and racism that makes your virtual silence on the issue of homosexuality so puzzling.
To your credit, in your book To Live is Christ: The Life and Ministry of Paul, you wrote, “I met a young man who had experienced freedom from the bondage of homosexuality” (pg. 119). This book was first published in 1997 and then republished in 2008 but it seems since then you have said very little if anything publicly about this issue.
Another factor prompting our open letter to you is the very public mutual affection and admiration between you, Jen Hatmaker and Jonathan Merritt.
Jen Hatmaker and you regularly exchange affirming posts of one another on social media. In just one recent example, Hatmaker on September 17, 2018 wrote “Beth Moore will enjoy my respect and devotion forever. She is worthy of being a mentor to an entire generation. And friends, I wish you knew how deeply and profoundly she has loved me these last two years” (Source). In an interview two years before this post, October of 2016, Jen Hatmaker said she was a “left-leaning moderate,” came out as fully supportive of homosexual marriage (saying it can be “holy”) and said practicing homosexuals can be part of the regenerate body of Christ (Source). It was then that LifeWay decided to pull all of her books from its shelves.
More recently, on April 9, 2019, Jonathan Merritt tweeted, “I no longer believe @BethMooreLPM is a human. I think she is an angelic being having a human experience.” (Source). Jonathan Merritt has admitted to having at least one homosexual encounter about a decade ago (Source). Today, by his own admission he rejects biblical inerrancy, says a “liberal Protestant” would be an accurate description of him, and says his sexual orientation he no longer views as “broken” (Source). In a crass response to Dr. Owen Strachan tweeting, rightly so, that there should never be an occasion in which men “cuddle” with one another, Merritt on May 1, 2019 tweeted in response, “C’mon, Owen. You can be my little spoon” (Source). Merritt also openly affirms that “queer” and LGBTQ people are included in God’s Kingdom and it is a “carrot of false promises” that the Gospel can make such people straight (Source, Source). He supports “Drag Queen Story Time” in which drag queens read stories to young children in public libraries (Source 27:40 mark). He even appears to doubt the exclusivity of Christ (Source).
Both Jen Hatmaker and Jonathan Merritt are known for their belief that practicing homosexuals can be Christians. Given that this is such a deeply held conviction that both share and this conviction (wrong though it is) has cost them both in their standing amongst theologically conservative evangelicals, and that they both praise you so highly, it raises the natural question as to where you stand on this issue.
Given his beliefs, Merritt publicly saying that he believes you to be “an angelic being having a human experience” strongly suggests that his high praise of you is, at least partially, rooted in your views on this issue that you have shared with him privately. It seems most unlikely that he would be praising you so highly if you had told him that as a homosexual man he will perish for all of eternity unless he repents. It likewise seems unlikely that Hatmaker (a married, straight woman) would praise you so highly if you told her that her affirmation of homosexuality and homosexual marriage is sinful and that she must repent.
When all of this is coupled with your total silence on homosexuality (in stark contrast to your very vocal stance on gender/racial/abuse issues) it naturally raises the question as to what your beliefs on it truly are.
With these factors in mind, and knowing that millions of people follow your teachings, we would like to ask you:
1. Do you believe homosexuality is inherently sinful?
2. Do you believe that the practice of the homosexual lifestyle is compatible with holy Christian living?
3. Do you believe a person who dies as a practicing homosexual but professes to be a Christian will inherit eternal life?
4. Do you believe same sex attraction is, in and of itself, an inherently sinful, unnatural, and disordered desire that must be mortified?
5. Why have you been so silent on this subject in light of your desire to “teach the word of God?”
We ask these questions to you out of genuine concern. As Bible teachers, all of us are held to a very high standard and will give an account for how we handle God’s word. As you know, homosexuality is widely discussed and debated amongst evangelicals and society at large.
Many families are affected by this issue. The most loving thing obedient Christians can do for them is to clearly communicate God’s truth. We look forward to your clarification on these pressing issues. Thank you.
Kind regards,
Susan Heck
With the Master
Debbie Lynne Kespert
The Outspoken Tulip
Michelle Lesley
Michelle Lesley- Discipleship for Christian Women
A Word Fitly Spoken Podcast
Martha Peace
Martha Peace
Elizabeth Prata
The End Time
Amy Spreeman
Berean Research
Naomi’s Table
A Word Fitly Spoken Podcast
Readers, if you would like to add your signature to this open letter, please comment below. (My regular comment parameters still apply.
Please read before commenting.)
Supportive comments will be considered signatures.
1. Debbie Gartland 2. Sherri Brazeal 3. Theresa Miller 4. Cheryl Thompson
5. Jamie Gladden 6. MrsHLBjr 7. Sue Layman 8. Dottie Gephart
9. Laura Moses 10. Cynthia Sutton 11. Kristy Kapp 12. Andrea Crawford
13. Gina 14. Kimberly 15. Sarah Deringer 16. Laura Esther
17. Julie Waschuk 18. Britt Smith 19. Sybil Hemingway 20. Alma Moss
21. Nancy Brown 22. McKenzie Pope Moffett 23. Barbara Phillips
24. Anna Wood 25. Tami Recke 26. Amy Mabe 27. Jacy Harrison
28. Deena647 29. Kara Peters 30. Steph Johnson
31. Cristy Ann Bestwick 32. Jessica Laird 33. Lydia Hamre
34. Pat Seitz 35. Cindy Duncan-Shaw 36. Cathy Wentzel
37. Linda Rios 38. Kelley Andrich 39. Kelly Jo 40. Katie Smith
41. Amanda Ridenour 42. Melissa Leigh Morris 43. Erika Morris
44. Pam 45. Ann Blaskovich 46. Molly Hoverson 47. Linda Culp Collier
48. Heather Brownlie McCuaig 49. Ginger Weincek 50. Shelley Brown
51. Lauren Hereford 52. Miyoshig 53. Jeri Lowe-Howell 54. Angela
55. Kelly Cason 56. Kris Turrentine 57. Lisa Carey 58. Darlene Doss
60. Annie Monserrate 61. Cheryl R Lamz 62. Maribel C Ibrahim
63. sgoetz78 64. Caitlin Wickliffe 65. Regina Hagan 66. Anne R.
67. Julie Harrod 68. Katie Jay 69. Dawn Staton 70. Susan
71. Jennifer Buck 72. Amy Andrews 73. Stephanie Madrigal 74. triplejaymom
75. Cindy LaFreniere 76. Sharon Cole 77. Julie Fugate 78. Kathy Peters
79. Mrs. Lisor 80. Robin Sykee 81. Lisa King 82. Susan 83. Lisa Brown
84. Eileen Smith 85. Karen McMahon 86. Cathy Kaech 87. Carie Stephens
88. Kim Chapman 89. Cheryl Toepfer 90. Nancy Madrick 91. Linda Sullivan
92. Brittany Hunt 93. Anne Mai 94. Maureen Kopper 95. Julie Norton
96. Debbie Fleig 97. Hilary Osborne 98. Maggie Hebert 99. Leigh Melniszyn
100. Erin Coughlin 101. Laurel Pinske 102. Alicia Bowman 103. Jori Groen
104. Laura Gutwein 105. Nicole B. Guillory 106. Lisa Mifflin
107. Kristine Stone 108. Carol Anne 109. Rachel Lipski 110. Laura Smith
111. jacor13 112. Traci Danker 113. Christina Pountney
114. Elizabeth Jackson 115. Marita Tibbetts 116. Amy Ramey
117. Maygen Wilson 118. Mary Bradley-Carlson 119. Allison Smith
120. Sandra 121. Courtney Sharp 122. Barb Prihoda 123. Penny Humphreys
124. Jan Bennett 125. Ren Moody 126. Trish Hisle 127. Heidi Moody
128. Carey Hurlburt 129. Kate Skogstad 130. Suzanne Lukawski
131. Elizabeth Beales 132. Susan Tesauro 133. Carol Koprowski
134. Christine Pack 135. Susan Stribich 136. Becka Goings
137. Pamela Thomas 138. Deborah Hunter 139. Mo Weaver
140. Kim Roberts 141. Corrie Dove 142. Lauren Holladay
143. Patty Roberts 144. Beth Stark 145. Sarah Crow 146. Sofia Shapleigh
147. Carnata Horton 148. Dulce Rodejo 149. Heather Fernandez
150. Carolyn Sevier 151. Christine Dullea 152. Amanda Gardiner
153. Char Hartman 154. Susan Haymon 155. Audra Huntet 156. Karla Nunez
157. Debra Pendergraft 158. Debbie 159. Leah P. 160. Sissel Salayda
161. Stephanie Yearwood 162. Melissa Harrison 163. tamtam0101
164. Anita Meisen 165. Elizabeth Moyle 166. Karen Gregory
167. Kate Thompson 168. Shannon Choate 169. Carol Berubee
170. Michele Harden 171. Lisa Snyder 172. Camille Warren
173. Diane Wenning 174. Nancy Nuzzolo 175. Kylee Chavers
176. Lynda Foster 177. Patricia Sanford 178. Jessica Lam
179. Brooke Anglin 180. Heidi Pearce 181. Michele Archambault
182. Michele Lewis 183. Pat Guldenpfennig 184. Angela Asano
185. Sue Cryderman 186. Jacqueline Cody 187. Theresia Smith
188. Peggy Summers 189. Lora M Carver 190. Regina Bean
191. Camille Patterson 192. Kate Butler 193. Leisa Minear
194. Ellie Mae Stankus 195. Tina Nix 196. Linda Currans
197. Daniela Ledwick 198. Melissa Flowers 199. flippingtheswitch
200. Vicky Jackson 201. Cherice Graham 202. Lora Burdette
203. Linda Hughes 204. Heather Ells 205. Jessica Harris
206. Kim von olhausen 207. Cynthia Garcia 208. Norleen Gardner Cheser
209. C. G. Jackson 210. Liz Avrit 211. Charlotte Irons Augustine
212. Tammera Scrivner 213. Donna Nelson 214. Susan Johnson
215. Qiana S. Shaw 216. Donna Dabbs 217. deuteronomysix5to9
218. Tiet Parsons 219. Marline Coronado 220. Julie Wyatt 221. Shelly Howard
222. Janice Porter Huertas 223. Lea K. Housley 224. Bonnie Secrest
225. Julie McKenzie 226. Terri Weiford 227. Pamela Melland
228. Diane E Ellison 229. Cherice Graham 230. Becky U
231. ruthsreminiscings 232. Darlene Tan 233. Kim Starling 234. Candy Macy
235. Rebecca Walls 236. Amy Scott 237. lynettestalls4146
238. Jammie Burwell 239. psfair 240. Laura Flack 241. Kayleigh H.
242. Cel Sherer 243. Kristy Jackson 244. Autumn Lisor 245. Julie Matteson
246. Keri Drescher 247. Name later removed for online anonymity 248. Hayley Wiley 249. Grace Pimm
250. Melanie Carrel 251. Lora Schmitz 252. Julie Wood 253. lauranlou
254. Pamela Collier 255. Coleen Thomas 256. Linda Hughes 257. Becky Bizzell
258. Debbie Lund 259. Connie Gilliam 260. Brandy Hurley
261. Linda Sola Gratia 262. Emily Kelly 263. Gracia 264. Sandie Fields
265. Erika Luft 266. Jennifer Sanders 267. Esther Wood 268. Trina Armstrong
269. tburks0123 270. Cathy Stein 271. Angela Fletcher 272. bjhcfr
273. Abby Adams 274. Diana 275. Cindy Price 276. Karen Buttle
277. Beth Seifert 278. Gemma Gregory 279. Julie Six 280. Colleen Ridge
281. Brenda Klockenga 282. Mary Bausano 283. Heather Thompson
284. Deana Klarich 285. Cheri Briere 286. Frankie Peterson
287. Charlotte Warren 288. Daphne Self 289. Billie J Freeman 290. Tara Hiley
291. Lou Ann Platt 292. I. N. Carpenter 293. Rachel Capps 294. Emily Tucker
295. Elena C. Parr 296. Julie Martin 297. lex122083 298. RM Vicary
299. Tania Carr 300. Sonia Correa 301. Wanda Poudrette 302. Lisa Israel
303. Kelly Gilmore 304. Melissa Ice 305. Michele Smith 306. Natalie Zeiler
307. Sonia Shoultz 308. MJ 309. Kandi Veazey 310. Haley Phillips
311. Kim Francia 312. Janexsy Zayas 313. Debra Hausmann
314. Patricia Finch 315. Bethany 316. Ashley Wyly 317. Amanda Smith
318. Wendy Robinson 319. Lara Roberts 320. Robin Hayes
321. Maggie Pearson 322. Slone Chapman 323. Dawn Antczak
324. Loretta Pardo 325. Autumn Beck 326. Casey Hylton
327. Sonya McGowan 328. Elaine Harman 329. Melissa Googe
330. Leisa Minear 331. Starr Bowlin 332. Jamie Niederkohr
333. Andrea Thomas 334. Tennille Betker 335. Debbie Nateghi
336. Cindy Price 337. Linda Brown 338. Rhonda Gomez 339. Liz James
340. Laura Burton 341. Jamie Dollinger 342. Christie Ann Algeo
343. Kerri Wagner 344. Amy Wood 345. Amy Hall 346. Beth Malarkey
347. Jo Vazquez 348. Cindy Mock 349. Christine Combs 350. Catherine- BBF
351. Kim- BBF 352. Vicki- BBF 353. Tina- BBF 354. Tara- BBF
355. Cate- BBF 356. Patti- BBF 356. Anonymous- BBF 357. Pamela Couvrette
358. Doris Sparks 359. Deborah Hallman 360. Cyndy Adeniyi
361. Laurie Ingram 362. Susan 363. Kay Cude 364. Melanie Lockhart
365. Leah Johnson 366. Jeni Myers 367. Keri Stankova 368. Tanya Herring
369. B Logue 370. Charlotte Sutton 371. ameliavk 372. Jannelle Kodad
373. Debbie Nateghi 374. Lynette 375. Heaven Henderson 376. Jennifer Rice
377. Michelle David 378. Karen Butterfield 379. Sheila H. Bragg
380. Angela Wismer 381. Karen Short 382. Pamela Ellenburg
383. Danielle Ware 384. Emily George 385. April Chapman 386. Gayle Smith
387. Liz Maria 388. Kris Schlagel 389. Amanda Simkins 390. Julie Garber
391. Hope Green 392. Nicole Mitchell 393. Rachelle Journey
394. Chrissy Reimer 395. Margaret Gunden 396. Maureen Payne
397. Rebecca Barner 398. Melissa Armstrong 399. Holly Major 400. Lisa PS
401. Linda Rice 402. Nancy Carrera 403. Katy Alderton 404. Christine Frost
405. Renee J. Bailey 406. Amberly Wieler 407. Susan K 408. Katie Purvis
409. Valerie Ward 410. Alise Grant 411. mvfreeman 412. Jo Rodgers
413. Mitzi Turpin 414. Tina Liouzis 415. Marsha West 416. Christine Parfitt
417. Leslie J. Witty 418. Victoria Nelson 419. Leah Stewart
420. Nancy Carrera 421. Lydia Harris 422. karolewithak 423. Diane Conklin
424. Tammy Monson 425. Katie Quintana 426. Diane Kelley 427. Carole Kaetz
428. Jessica Oathoudt 429. Valerie Muirhead 430. Lisa Schmidt
431. Kim Schwart 432. Raynie Sivillo 433. Lisa Ente 434. Tina Dewey
435. Amy. Rozycki 436. Jennifer Christensen 437. Christa Reynolds
439. Kathy Freeman 440. Traci Gardner 441. Debbie Landers 442. caligurrl61
443. Melissa McIntyre 444. Kim 445. Valerie Hupp 446. Sharon Buss
447. Kira Ulmer 448. Brittany Bieghler 449. Nicole Bibelheimer McAbee
450. Sandy Bitter 451. Monica Turner 452. Elizabeth Emerson
453. Kara Emerson 454. Janice Krieger 455. Peggy M. Miller
456. Cecelia Matchett 457. Wendi Peterson 458. LeDawn Kosek
459. Dianne Larios 460. Rhonda Owens 461. Kathleen Lanteigne
462. Terra Hicks 463. Brenda Block 464. Lisa Ente 465. Sarah Elizabeth
466. Darlene Diaz 467. Debra Wiest 468. Lyndsey Fromme 469. Laurie Tietjen
470. Connie Windham 471. Gladys Martínez 472. Beth Cavete 473. Linda Bell
474. Beth Finkbeiner 475. Heather Rollins 476. Charla Counts Tatom
477. Ose Burnett 478. Kathy Firth 479. Debbie Bergt 480. J Chen
481. Melissa Duerksen 482. Kate Hendrickson 483. Miranda Abugharbeya
484. Gisele Krippner 485. Robin Kelley 486. Kari 487. Maggie Gunden
488. Mollie Moore 489. Diana Johnson 490. Stacy Brooks 491. Gina Shaw
492. Kellie Watson 493. Bonnie Schwartz 494. Kay Davis 495. Lisa
496. Rosilind Jukic 497. Laura Kelly 498. Sandy Artus 499. Clare McNaul
500. Tami 501. Diane Ostrow 502. Amanda Ladefoged 503. Bev Azure
504. Hayley Bevier 505. Mary L. Briere 506. Rommy Miller 507. Tammy Derryberry
508. Billie Freeman 509. Amy Knight
Michelle Lesley 