The Peterson Predicament and LifeWay’s Peculiar Policies

Last week, the news broke that Eugene Peterson, author of The Message, (a popular mutilation paraphrase of the Bible) has, for quite some time, held the position that there’s nothing wrong with homosexuality, that he was on staff at a church that considered hiring a homosexual minister of music, and that he would perform a homosexual wedding if asked. (It was quite the kerfuffle. Play by play at the end of this article if you’re interested.)

LifeWay quickly – and rightly – released a statement saying that if they could verify that these are, in fact, Peterson’s beliefs, they would pull “The Message” and all of his other materials from their stores.

The next day, Peterson publicly retracted his statement about being willing to perform a same sex wedding – saying he affirms the biblical view of marriage – and LifeWay said they’d keep his materials on the shelf.

I commend LifeWay for pulling authors who support homosexuality. That’s a good and right thing and I don’t want to minimize it. This is absolutely something they should do, and I’m glad this is their policy.

However, what about the fact that The Message is such a poor and misleading paraphrase that, as many have said, it should never have been on the shelves at LifeWay in the first place?

What about the fact that Eugene Peterson wrote a front cover endorsement for The Shack– a book that teaches the heresies of universalism, patripassianism, and blasphemies regarding the Trinity? Why was that sin not grievous enough, but his endorsement of homosexuality was?

When LifeWay only makes a splash in the media about removing books whose authors endorse homosexuality, they’re sending two very important messages:

1. Things like false doctrine, female authors/celebrities who defy Scripture by preaching to men, and teachers and authors who disobey God’s word by partnering with false teachers, don’t matter. All that matters is if you’re on the right side of homosexuality.

2. It sends the message to homosexuals and the rest of the world – not to mention members of our own SBC churches – that Southern Baptists think homosexuality is the worst sin out there and the only one we really care about people repenting from.

How hypocritical that LifeWay will turn a blind eye to Beth Moore’s sins of teaching false doctrine, preaching to men, and partnering with false teachers, and make her a wealthy celebrity, but will take a stand against other authors (whose materials don’t sell as well as Moore’s) for the sin of endorsing homosexuality.

Sin is sin in God’s eyes, but not in LifeWay’s, apparently.

Play by Play of the Peterson Predicament

Wednesday, July 12:
News breaks that Eugene Peterson has “changed his mind” regarding the biblical view of marriage.
LifeWay announces that if Peterson’s remarks can be confirmed, they will cease selling all of his materials including The Message.

Thursday, July 13:
Peterson retracts his original comments about same sex marriage and says he “affirms a biblical view of marriage.”
LifeWay announces that, due to the retraction, they will continue to carry Peterson’s materials.
♦ The reporter (Jonathan Merritt) who originally broke the Peterson story offers his take and behind the scenes insights on the retraction.
♦ In an additional article, Merritt offers evidence that Peterson made statements affirming homosexuality as recently as 2014.

7 thoughts on “The Peterson Predicament and LifeWay’s Peculiar Policies”

  1. Yes, good points!
    And to be honest, I feel like Peterson’s comment that he “affirms a biblical view of marriage” might be a little bit sneaky as well, since there are many people (like Matthew Vines) who claim that a Biblical view of marriage is in fact supportive of homosexual marriages.
    So it kind of seems like he’s trying to make a comment that’s not technically a lie, but is enough to appease Lifeway.


  2. I appreciate so much, Mrs. Lesley, that you always bring in other parts of the Bible or other Biblical principles. The tunnel-vision that many Christians have toward homosexuality is very frustrating. Remarriage can be just as sinful as homosexual marriage, but no one ever refused to bake a cake for a second marriage. I am sinner and so is everyone else. Focusing on only one type of sin is not doing anyone any favors.


  3. Oh, I think Peterson lied indeed if what you have said is true. I’ve known others who will do an immediate reversal on their stated belief about something if they are strongly redacted or called to the carpet. They will back peddle hard as heck….”well, I didn’t mean that…” It’s called “lying”.
    Peterson also wrote a cover endorsement for Rob Bell’s, Love Wins, book. No why didn’t that cause Lifeway to avoid all of Peterson’s writings, including the Message?

    Lifeway is well-aware of the growing body of exposure of Beth Moore’s false teaching but she is their cash cow, after all….

    And they continue to sell books by modalist (nontrinitarian heresy) T. D. Jakes and other false teachers…you know…because they sell well. Furthermore, I don’t get how Trevin Wax, author of the great book, Counterfeit Gospels, can justify his current employment by Lifeway….the keeper of counterfeit gospel teachers.


Before commenting please see the "Welcome" tab in the blue menu bar at the top of this page. Comments are handled manually, so there will be a delay before approved comments are posted. I do not publish comments which promote false doctrine.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.